Transport | Policy Brief
Evaluating the Recast Directive
02 September 2024
BY: Matthias Finger, Juan José Montero Pascual, VAN DER VEER Anouk
The Recast Directive opens the single European railway area to competition. Competition is gradually emerging across the EU but there are obvious asymmetries among Member States, in particular in the commercial passenger sector, which includes high-speed services (see RMMS 2023, Figure 79). While some markets have vibrant competition in high-speed services, others have competition for the market in public service obligation services, yet in some markets no significant evolution has taken place. Barriers to entry in railway markets are particularly relevant. Rail infrastructure is a natural monopoly. Traditionally, infrastructure managers were vertically integrated and enjoyed exclusive rights to provide downstream rail services (freight, passenger, etc.). The elimination of these exclusive rights enables competition in commercial services and public service obligation (PSO) services. However, barriers to entry can deter newcomers. Access to infrastructure is a key factor, as in other network industries, as is access to service facilities. The Recast Directive aims to reduce the barriers to entry related to access to infrastructure: rules on capacity allocation, traffic management, temporary capacity restrictions, etc. Furthermore, it defines the basic principle of non-discrimination by infrastructure managers in favour of vertically integrated railway undertakings when vertical integration exists, and specific rules for the governance of vertically integrated undertakings. Article 63 of the Recast Directive requires the Commission to evaluate the impact of the Directive by the end of 2024, and in particular to draft a report assessing whether discriminatory practices or other types of distortion of competition persist in relation to infrastructure managers which are part of a vertically integrated undertaking, and in particular to evaluate the development of high-speed rail services and assess the existence of discriminatory practices regarding access to high-speed lines. The 25th Florence Rail forum, co-organised by the Transport Area of the Florence School of Regulation together with the European Commission’s DG MOVE, discussed the current situation of competition in the Single European Railway Area. Are there discriminatory practices or other types of distortion of competition in relation to vertically integrated infrastructure managers? What is the impact on the market? How is competition in high-speed evolving? Has vertical integration impacted the evolution of competition? How are the rules to govern vertically integrated infrastructure managers implemented? Are they effective? What new rules should be introduced?
logo cadmus Read it on Cadmus Download in open access

LATEST FSR PUBLICATIONS

Dataset
This dataset aims to provide a list of installation entries and exits into and from the EU ETS. To the extent possible, we also specify the reason for an identified [...]
Article
Purpose of the Review: The increasing penetration of distributed energy sources into the electricity system requires greater customer engagement in providing new flexibility services. This article reviews the main behavioural [...]
Other
In the Commission’s Industrial Carbon Management Strategy it acknowledges the importance of CCUs, and that without it the EU will not succeed in its Green deal and Net Zero ambitions. [...]
Other
As the 2021 EU urban mobility framework states, Europe is one of the most urbanised regions in the world with a huge variety of cities that are important economic and [...]
Working Paper
For decades, environmental degradation has been the focus of public opinion, academia, research centers, and institutions. This attention is motivated by increasing awareness of the severe ecological and socio-economic problems [...]
Other
This policy brief, written in May 2024, provides an overview of the international carbon market landscape and describes the status quo in terms of the degree of its integration and [...]

Join our community

To meet, discuss and learn in the channel that suits you best.

scroll

top