logo-eui RSCAS
FSR

Electricity


Electricity

Publications

7.03.2019

Book on Electricity Network Regulation in the EU

Electricity network regulation in the EU: the challenges ahead‎ for transmission and distribution Edited by L. Meeus, (FSR, Vlerick Business School); J.M. Glachant (FSR, Loyola […] read more

Electricity

Event Highlights

22.02.2019

Nodal Vs Zonal Pricing for the Electricity Market

On Friday 25 January 2019, the Florence School of Regulation hosted the Policy Workshop: ‘Nodal Vs Zonal Pricing for the Electricity Market’ to debate the […] read more

ElectricityEnergy Policy

Interview

11.02.2019

Zonal versus Nodal Electricity Pricing: the PJM experience

New podcast interview with Vincent P. Duane, Senior Vice-President at PJM Today, in Europe electricity prices are determined per bidding zone which equals in most cases a […] read more

Electricity

Which standard should be implemented for charging electric vehicle batteries?

by C. Crampes and Y. Lefouili (Toulouse School of Economics) The development of electric vehicles is hampered by batteries which discharge too quickly and charge […] read more

Electricity

News

28.01.2019

Open Africa Power | FSR in Ethiopia with Enel Foundation

The course starts today in Ethiopia! Open Africa Power is an education venture initiated by Enel Foundation in 2018 in partnership with top Academic institutions such as Strathmore […] read more

ElectricityEnergy

Regulated Access to Incumbent Nuclear Electricity

by Stefan Ambec and Claude Crampes (Toulouse School of Economics) For the first time since its creation by the NOME law in 2010, the mechanism […] read more

Electricity

Topic of the Month

10.01.2019

Procuring Energy Efficiency: Regulatory Implications for Auction Design

FSR Topic of the Month Energy efficiency: a market-based approach for distributed energy resources by Tiago de Barros Correia Procuring Energy Efficiency: Regulatory Implications for […] read more

Electricity

6th EU-India Smart Grid Workshop

Event Highlights

20.12.2018

Key Insights from the 6th EU-India Smart Grids Workshop

The Florence School of Regulation hosted the 6th EU-India Smart Grids Workshop from 19 to 22 November 2018 in collaboration with the European Commission and […] read more

Electricity

News

18.12.2018

Power Summit 2019 | Call for contributions!

NEW LEADERSHIP FROM NEW TECHNOLOGIES, NEW BUSINESSES, NEW ENTREPRENEURS                 Eurelectric and The Florence School of Regulation are […] read more

Page 1 of 1412345Next ›Last »

Nodal Vs Zonal Pricing for the Electricity Market

- Electricity

On Friday 25 January 2019, the Florence School of Regulation hosted the Policy Workshop: ‘Nodal Vs Zonal Pricing for the Electricity Market’ to debate the possible benefits and relative challenges of implementing a nodal market structure in the European electricity market.

The event was structured in two sessions. The first reviewed the international experience with nodal and zonal pricing, including their impact on market liquidity and efficiency. The audience engaged with scholars and practitioners with direct experience in these markets to discuss the main opportunities and challenges such pricing structures pose. This discussion subsequently introduced the second session, focusing on the potential for Europe to adopt a nodal market design.

The event caught the interest of a vast variety of stakeholders: generators and suppliers, energy traders, power exchanges, transmission system operators, national regulatory authorities, European and national policy-makers. The majority of the academics were in favour of nodal pricing, whereas the various stakeholders expressed a more nuanced view. Some were mildly in favour of nodal prices, while others clearly supported a zonal approach.

Increased efficiency in the dispatch of the generating units and reduced re-dispatching costs were highlighted as one of the most relevant benefits of introducing nodal pricing. By better signalling local grid conditions, nodal pricing would provide generators and consumers with adequate incentives, taking into account the physical constraints, both when investing in new capacity and when trading energy on the wholesale market. With the ongoing transformation of the generation mix, such incentives are extremely important and could reduce the overall costs of the energy transition.  On the other hand, nodal prices do not provide system operators with optimal signals for the grid expansion, nor do they ensure the recovery of the grid’s fixed costs. Moreover, for some of the attendees, the introduction of nodal pricing may decrease the liquidity in wholesale markets and allow, under certain circumstances, some market players to exert stronger market power.

The debate highlighted the fact that beyond any theoretical merit or drawback, policy-makers should be aware of the costs of moving from one system to another and the political obstacles that may prevent a smooth transition. Indeed, several stakeholders suggested that the current European governance of the electricity system would be unfit for a change in the pricing method. In their view, it would be easier and wiser to first fully implement the existing rules and improve the implementation of zonal pricing before venturing into the introduction of nodal prices.

In conclusion, important challenges lie ahead of the European energy sector. To advance in the decarbonisation strategy, some changes in the current system need to be considered and new solutions have to be investigated. A quantitative investigation of the benefits and costs of moving towards a nodal system could be helpful to understand if some elements of such market design could be gradually applied to the current framework.

Browse the photo gallery from the workshop:

Zonal vs Nodal Pricing for the Electricity Markets

Learn more in our Publications:

 

Join FSR Energy & Climate Community

Subscribe to our Newsletter

JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
What topics are you interested in?

Florence School of Regulation will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates about our upcoming online and residential events, publications and other activities.All you need to do to receive insightful updates from us is to click the button below:

You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at daniela.bernardo@eui.eu. Personal data will be processed in accordance with the EUI’s Data Protection Policy (President’s Decision No. 40 of 27 August 2013 regarding Data Protection at the EUI) as well as under the specific modalities outlined in the Privacy statement for events organised at the Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies. We will treat your information with respect. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.