Climate | Policy Brief
Comparison of ex-ante modelling assessments of emissions trading - 2023
02 February 2024
- This policy brief synthesises the results from the first annual workshop on ex-ante assessment of emissions trading. It focuses on models assessing the schemes in the EU, UK, China, California, and Québec. - At a time when emissions trading systems (ETSs) are increasing in number and face similar issues, only a few comparisons of ex-ante models exist. - The models show considerable heterogeneity. The differences stem from the specific aim, design, scope, ambition and maturity of each market modelled. - Regarding modelling assumptions, there is an overall reliance of models on Marginal Abatement Cost Curves (MACCs) and a strong impact of parameters such as the discount rate on the assessments. - In terms of predicted prices, an overall increasing trend is observed across jurisdictions, with predicted prices of non-EU ETSs remaining at a lower level than EU prices. This divergence is due to uncertainty regarding abatement costs, scope, maturity, and overlapping policies. - There is a growing interest in capturing market imperfections and investor behaviour. Evaluation of carbon leakage, which still requires extensive modelling work, is also identified as relevant future model extensions. - There is a need for discussion on model comparison to include industry feedback, share experiences and improve the robustness of modelling assumptions. - Closing the loop between the policy process and modelling work is necessary to enhance the predictability of carbon markets and to showcase the consequences of different policy and design choices. Models may also be useful to attribute certain effects to either ETS policies or other policies. This can ultimately improve our understanding of carbon markets in an increasingly dynamic policy landscape.
logo cadmus Read it on Cadmus Download in open access

LATEST FSR PUBLICATIONS

Dataset
This dataset is composed of five indicators which provide information on the economic and environmental performance of sectors covered by the European Union’s Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS). The focus [...]
Other
On 21 February 2024 the European Commission Directorate General for Mobility and Transport in cooperation with the Florence School of Regulation hosted an academic conference to explore opportunities and challenges [...]
Other
Rail has a key role to play in making transport more efficient and sustainable in the EU and elsewhere. However, increasing passenger and cargo volumes require investment in infrastructure, and [...]
Technical Report
In this work, we present the major application and impact areas of Contracts-for-Difference (CfDs) in a European context, describe the most relevant design dimensions and discuss several design packages for [...]
Other
After years of record announcements, frantic policy development and the establishment of substantial public support mechanisms, the clean hydrogen sector is nearing an inflexion point. Many clean hydrogen projects have [...]
Other
The safeguarding of critical offshore energy infrastructure has assumed a heightened level of urgency in the wake of the Nord Stream pipeline explosions in September 2022 and the suspected sabotage [...]

Join our community

To meet, discuss and learn in the channel that suits you best.

scroll

top